6e992cc0c5
- Rename 'three-pronged' folder to 'knowledge-layers' — prong metaphor
was misleading (implied parallel tines), replaced with epistemic layers
(deductive base, empirical middle, probabilistic oracle — vertical stack)
- Collapse 11 overlapping files into 3 coherent documents:
- knowledge-layers/_index.org: core framework (two engines + one store,
World Model formula, 0-14 layer table, provenance store design,
conflict resolution, cold-start, stage mapping)
- knowledge-layers/practical-implications.org: design-world-aware-of-
physics, 10 powers, Schafmeister existence proof, epistemic transparency
- knowledge-layers/neurological-empirical.org: neural networks in
provenance framework (kept intact)
- Relocate wolfram/mathematica and Schafmeister docs to ideas/viability/
- Integrate into main architecture _index.org:
- Gate: expanded from two vectors (ACL2+LLM) to three (deductive,
provenance/empirical, LLM oracle)
- Autodidactic loop: split into Track 1 (deductive hardening, fast)
and Track 2 (empirical validation, slow, experimental-feedback-driven)
- See also: added Knowledge Layers cross-reference
- Add all-lisp geometry engine note (ideas/lisp-geometry-engine.org) as
concrete illustration of the empirical layer's effect on design work
- Rebuild site: 148 files, 0 errors
3.8 KiB
Server Rack Build
- Overview
- Current topology
- Chassis
- Platform decision (TBD)
- GPU decision (TBD)
- Memory plan
- Build order (over months)
- Questions still open
- Strategic framing
Overview
Building out a 10-20U open rack, server-grade components bought individually over months. This is the first racked node — triple duty as Passepartout host, Proxmox home server, and ZFS array. Node-1 (Protectli, i7, 6 NICs) stays as network edge.
Already have 10Gb networking, that's stable.
Current topology
- Node-1 (Protectli): Small form factor, i7, 6 NICs, no PCIe, no GPU, limited RAM. Network appliance / router.
- Node-2 (racked): First rack server. Passepartout + Proxmox + ZFS + GPU for local Hermes inference.
Chassis
- 3U or 4U rackmount
- Room for full-height GPU, hot-swap drive bays, sufficient airflow
- Open rack design, 10-20U growable
Platform decision (TBD)
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Intel Xeon 6 (Granite Rapids) | Newest arch, 12-ch DDR5, 136 PCIe 5.0 lanes, AMX AI accelerators | LGA 4710 (new socket, new mobo cost), DDR5 only, expensive |
| AMD EPYC 7002 (Rome) | 128 PCIe 4.0 lanes, 8-ch DDR4, cheap on used market | Older gen, DDR4 (slower, but cheap), no AMX |
| AMD EPYC 9004/9005 (Genoa/Turin) | 160 PCIe 5.0 lanes, 12-ch DDR5 | More expensive than 7002, but current gen |
GPU decision (TBD)
Local inference for Hermes. Candidates:
| Option | VRAM | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intel Arc Pro B70 | 32 GB GDDR6 | ~$949 MSRP | Battlemage workstation, air-cooled, 230W, PCIe 5.0 x16. Plug-and-play with standard toolchains. |
| Tenstorrent P150 (Blackhole) | 32 GB GDDR6 | ~$1,399 | RISC-V Tensix, open source stack, 300W. Software less mature, needs tt-forge compilation. 4x QSFP-DD for linking cards. |
| RTX 5090 | 32 GB GDDR7 | ~$2,000 | CUDA, best software ecosystem. Consumer card, may need blower mod for rack. |
| RTX 6000 Ada (used) | 48 GB GDDR6 | ~$4-5K used | More VRAM, enterprise. Higher price even used. |
Key consideration on P150: not CUDA, not a GPU in the conventional sense. Software maturity is the main cost, not the hardware price.
Memory plan
Start with 2×64GB DDR5 ECC RDIMM, grow to 4×64GB → 8×64GB (full 512GB on 8-channel; or 384GB on 12-channel).
Tradeoff: running fewer DIMMs than full channel count reduces memory bandwidth proportionally. 2 DIMMs on 8-channel = 25% bandwidth. First to suffer: ZFS ARC performance, VM responsiveness. Compute (LLM inference) is fine since GPU has own VRAM.
Alternative: start with 4×64GB to get half bandwidth without crippling storage I/O, then grow to 8×64GB.
Build order (over months)
- Rack + chassis + PSU
- Motherboard + CPU + RAM + boot drives (runs Proxmox + ZFS immediately)
- HDDs for ZFS array (start with 2, grow)
- GPU (last piece — when inference workload justifies it)
Questions still open
- Intel Xeon 6 vs AMD EPYC (which gen)?
- DDR4 (EPYC 7002) vs DDR5 (everything else)?
- GPU: Intel Arc Pro B70 vs Tenstorrent P150 vs RTX 5090?
- Start with 2×64GB or 4×64GB on memory?
- Water cooling for CPU (Xeon 6 TDP may need it) or just air?
- Specific rack model / chassis model?
Strategic framing
This node is a bootstrap between Stage 0 (current, conventional) and Stages 3-4 (Lisp machine, bare-metal, in-process LLM on dedicated silicon). DDR4's bandwidth ceiling won't matter because:
- Proxmox + ZFS + the Gate (Stage 2) don't stress 8-channel DDR4-3200
- GPU inference uses its own VRAM, not system memory
- By the time the Lisp machine arrives (different hardware entirely), this node graduates to NAS / Proxmox host duty
Part availability risk is acceptable — at 7+ years of life, the build has already paid for itself many times over, and a motherboard failure means re-platforming onto whatever is current, not trying to resurrect DDR4 infrastructure.