cc3976fb7f
- Split competitive-analysis-2026-05.org → TOC + 9 competitor files in ideas/competitors/. Dropped date from filename. All competitor UUIDs generated, TOC keeps original UUID for backlink continuity. - Deleted passepartout-economics.org archive (replaced by 27-node KB). - Inlined 5 'See also' blocks into natural prose (compliance-index, first-mover-window, revenue-table, orders-of-magnitude-time, native-org-knowledge-base). - Linked 7 orphan compliance pages back to compliance index + finished truncated sentences. - Linked all 14 Agora requirement docs from topic-relevant pages (identity→lisp-machine-security, infrastructure→compute-marketplace, social-space→growth-strategy, exchange→agora-contracts, etc.). - Linked ai-industry-impact from investment-thesis, sufficiency-flip, verification-appliance, effects-growth-flywheel (up from 1 to 10+ pages). - Fixed CREATED timestamps to use git commit dates instead of today. - Made all links absolute from root (no port inheritance). - Removed stale agora/docs/ duplicate content.
23 lines
2.4 KiB
Org Mode
23 lines
2.4 KiB
Org Mode
:PROPERTIES:
|
|
:ID: 416bab7c-4300-4d50-838a-5c7a8ad45d96
|
|
:CREATED: [2026-05-22 Thu]
|
|
:END:
|
|
#+title: Thoth — Personal AI Sovereignty
|
|
#+filetags: :passepartout:strategy:competitive:thoth:
|
|
|
|
https://github.com/siddsachar/Thoth — Python, ~151K lines, Apache 2.0. Local-first desktop AI assistant with knowledge graph, tools, voice, vision, shell, browser automation, workflow engine, and messaging channels.
|
|
|
|
Architecture: LangGraph create_react_agent (prebuilt ReAct pattern). Dual-mode streaming. NiceGUI web UI with desktop launcher. Context trimming via tiktoken, base64 data redaction, stale browser snapshot compression, MD5 tool result dedup, old tool result summarization. Agent graph cached by tool set + model override. Checkpoints via LangGraph's SQLite-backed checkpointer. 30+ tool modules.
|
|
|
|
Safety model: Shell command classification with 17 blocked patterns, 30+ safe auto-execute prefixes, needs-approval for compound commands. Interactive interrupt for non-safe shell. Per-workflow safety modes (block/approve/allow_all). Prompt-injection defense (5 categories, detection-only). Filesystem workspace boundary. Opt-in Docker Sandbox. Destructive ops require confirmation. No sandboxing of agent runtime itself.
|
|
|
|
Data model: SQLite (WAL mode) at ~/.thoth/memory.db — shared between knowledge graph and legacy memory. Knowledge graph: SQLite (durable) + NetworkX MultiDiGraph (in-memory, rebuilt on startup) + FAISS vector index (semantic recall). 11 entity types, 67+ typed relations with 30+ LLM-produced aliases. Dream Cycle refinement pipeline. Config: JSON files. Keys in OS credential store.
|
|
|
|
Self-modification: Agent CAN create/update/delete skills via dedicated tools. Skill patching requires user confirmation + auto backup. Maximum 1 patch proposal per conversation. No tool to modify system prompts directly.
|
|
|
|
Verification: None formal. Update signature verification.
|
|
|
|
Key gap vs Passepartout: No deterministic gate stack — shell safety is pattern list, not typed gates. No proof system. No output guardrails. No neurosymbolic architecture. No Org-mode. No Merkle-tree memory. Knowledge graph is LLM-driven entity extraction — no structural integrity guarantees. Thoth's differentiation is the knowledge graph + Developer/Designer studios + embedded LangGraph framework, but still architecturally conventional.
|
|
|
|
See the full [[id:3aa22300-2f25-57b0-8787-9f199cc978b1][competitive analysis]] for the landscape view and comparison.
|