Files
hermes-brain/ideas/comparison-with-symbolics.org
Hermes cc3976fb7f ideas: editorial sweep — atomization, interlinking, restructuring
- Split competitive-analysis-2026-05.org → TOC + 9 competitor files in
  ideas/competitors/. Dropped date from filename. All competitor UUIDs
  generated, TOC keeps original UUID for backlink continuity.
- Deleted passepartout-economics.org archive (replaced by 27-node KB).
- Inlined 5 'See also' blocks into natural prose (compliance-index,
  first-mover-window, revenue-table, orders-of-magnitude-time,
  native-org-knowledge-base).
- Linked 7 orphan compliance pages back to compliance index + finished
  truncated sentences.
- Linked all 14 Agora requirement docs from topic-relevant pages
  (identity→lisp-machine-security, infrastructure→compute-marketplace,
  social-space→growth-strategy, exchange→agora-contracts, etc.).
- Linked ai-industry-impact from investment-thesis, sufficiency-flip,
  verification-appliance, effects-growth-flywheel (up from 1 to 10+ pages).
- Fixed CREATED timestamps to use git commit dates instead of today.
- Made all links absolute from root (no port inheritance).
- Removed stale agora/docs/ duplicate content.
2026-05-24 16:25:55 +00:00

1.4 KiB

Comparison with Symbolics Genera

Symbolics Genera (1980s) Passepartout (2020s)
Lines ~1,000,000 ~21,000 (self-driving target)
Developer-years ~10 years, large team ~1 year, 1-3 devs
OS Built from scratch in assembly + Lisp Runs on Linux (free OS layer)
Hardware Custom Lisp Machine (entire computer) PCIe card (FPGA or Tenstorrent)
Market $50K-$100K/seat $5K-$50K/appliance
Scope Full OS + environment Cognitive agent + hardware acceleration

The Symbolics comparison is instructive: they built a full Lisp OS from scratch. Passepartout runs on Linux, providing the OS layer for free. The hardware integration is a PCIe card, not a replacement of the entire host. The scope is dramatically smaller — ~2% of the code for a fraction of the functionality that matters most. This illustrates the fundamental principles of Lisp economics — the cost of building a Lisp-based system has dropped by orders of magnitude since the 1980s. The Self-driving Lisp Machine is the modern analogue: a hardware accelerator rather than a complete computer.