5.5 KiB
Sovereign OS v1.0 Core Skill Audit Report
- Executive Summary
- Critical Skill Deep Dive
- Categorized Skill Audit
- Global Strategic Gaps
- Recommendations
Executive Summary
This audit evaluated all 39 Org files in the projects/org-agent/skills/ directory against the five core criteria for Sovereign OS v1.0. While the conceptual framework and topological foundations (IDs, Deterministic Engine hooks) are largely in place, significant implementation gaps exist in OACP compliance. The transition to Merkle-tree versioning is now COMPLETE in the core and primary persistence layers.
Overall Statistics
- Total Skills Scanned: 39
- Topological Integrity: ~85% (Most files have unique IDs; some depend on name-based strings)
- Deterministic Engine Safety: ~70% (Hooks exist, but symbolic verification logic is often stubbed)
- Persistence: ~100% (Merkle-tree logic is implemented in object-store.lisp and confirmed DONE in GTD)
- OACP Compliance: ~5% (Only 2/39 skills use
def-cognitive-tool) - Sovereignty Mandate: ~95% (High adherence to local-first, Lisp-native primitives)
Critical Skill Deep Dive
org-skill-agent (The Kernel)
- Status: STABLE / MANDATORY
- Topological Integrity: PASS (ID: 47425a43-2be0-423c-8509-22592cfe9c9e)
-
GAPS:
- Missing
def-cognitive-toolfor kernel introspection. - Deterministic Engine (Symbolic) logic is primarily a dispatcher; needs more robust "Moral Compass" invariants implemented in code.
- Missing
org-skill-lisp-validator (The Gatekeeper)
- Status: FUNCTIONAL / MANDATORY
- Topological Integrity: PASS (ID: 98576df2-c496-4e4a-9acb-0bca514a0305)
-
GAPS:
- Whitelist is comprehensive but needs a mechanism for skills to dynamically (and safely) register their own symbols.
- Missing
def-cognitive-toolfor security telemetry.
org-skill-self-fix (The Repair Mechanism)
- Status: PARTIAL / EXTENSION
- Topological Integrity: PARTIAL (Uses
skill-scientiststring instead of ID in#+DEPENDS_ON:) -
GAPS:
- Rollback logic depends on "Interactive Steering" snapshots which are not yet fully integrated with the Merkle-tree architecture.
- Missing
def-cognitive-tool.
org-skill-object-store-persistence (The Memory Image)
- Status: STABLE / MANDATORY
-
GAPS:
- MERKLE: COMPLIANT (Integrated with native Lisp Merkle-tree versioning).
- Missing background sync triggers beyond basic heartbeat.
org-skill-ast-normalization (The Structure Guardian)
- Status: BLUEPRINT-ONLY / MANDATORY
-
GAPS:
- CRITICAL: Implementation is missing. Functions like
ast-normalize-fileandfind-conflictsare defined in the blueprint but not tangled/implemented. - No integration with the Object Store for structural change tracking.
- CRITICAL: Implementation is missing. Functions like
Categorized Skill Audit
Core Mandatory
Foundational skills required for system boot and basic operation.
| Skill | ID | Gaps |
|---|---|---|
| org-skill-agent | 47425a43… | OACP compliance, deeper Deterministic Engine logic |
| org-skill-lisp-validator | 98576df2… | Dynamic whitelist registration |
| org-skill-ast-normalization | 1063668a… | Implementation missing (Blueprint only) |
| org-skill-object-store-persistence | e8b500e2… | COMPLIANT (Merkle-tree integrated) |
| org-skill-lisp-machine-bootstrap | 81e3492e… | Purely research/simulation stage |
| org-skill-auth-api-key | ab7f8ca4… | OACP compliance |
| org-skill-router | 0fb9e9cb… | Complexity classification is basic |
| org-skill-sub-agent-manager | e870d860… | Needs better thread isolation logic |
Provider
Interfaces to LLM backends.
| Skill | ID | Gaps |
|---|---|---|
| org-skill-provider-ollama | f605bf22… | OACP compliance, model discovery |
| org-skill-provider-gemini | 52799ee8… | OACP compliance |
| org-skill-provider-openai | c6cbd603… | OACP compliance |
| org-skill-provider-anthropic | a44d29c6… | OACP compliance |
Actuator
Sovereign interfaces for system modification.
| Skill | ID | Gaps |
|---|---|---|
| org-skill-shell-actuator | 0ae190ec… | Missing fine-grained permissions |
| org-skill-org-mode | f7db1884… | Needs better AST-to-JSON bridge integration |
| org-skill-inbound-gateway | 89ee87e0… | Multi-channel normalization is incomplete |
Extension
Feature-rich skills extending the kernel.
| Skill | ID | Gaps |
|---|---|---|
| org-skill-latent-reflection | latent-reflection | (OACP PASS) Needs more triggers |
| org-skill-memory-archivist | 98923a43… | (OACP PASS) IPFS restore is manual |
| org-skill-self-fix | 65891ce2… | Implementation/Rollback logic |
| org-skill-model-explorer | ae49bb72… | Implementation missing (Overview only) |
Global Strategic Gaps
1. OACP Compliance (Tooling Gap)
95% of skills do not use def-cognitive-tool. This means Probabilistic Engine cannot "discover" these capabilities autonomously; they must be hardcoded in the kernel or prompt, violating the PSF's extensibility mandate.
2. Topological Integrity (Refactoring Gap)
Dependency tracking is inconsistent. Some skills use id:UUID, others use skill-name. This prevents the Lisp machine from building a proper topological sort of the boot sequence.
3. Implementation Vacuum (Completeness Gap)
Critical skills like ast-normalization and model-explorer are currently "paper skills" (Blueprint/Overview only) and do not provide live functionality.
Recommendations
- Enforce OACP: Refactor all skills to use
def-cognitive-toolwith explicit schemas. - Normalize Dependencies: Standardize all
#+DEPENDS_ON:to use UUIDs. - Finish Mandatory Implementation: Prioritize the
ast-normalizationimplementation to ensure system-wide ID integrity.